2610 New Haven Avenue

Step into history with this extraordinary former St. Andrew’s Catholic Church, built in 1911 and offering well over 18,000 sq. ft., featuring stunning early 20th-century architecture. Nestled on 1.33 acres of private land, this versatile property boasts a 4600sq ft adjoined living quarters, two full kitchens, multiple bathrooms, and expansive outdoor spaces, including decks, terraces, and a fenced backyard sanctuary. The spacious dining hall/banquet area provides endless possibilities—whether you envision it as an event venue, restaurant, boutique hotel, or creative coworking space. This unique property could also be transformed into a brewery, yoga studio, wellness center, art gallery, or retail destination. It’s ideal for a nonprofit, community organization, or even an educational facility. For those seeking to preserve its original purpose, this space could easily continue to serve as a house of worship or religious community center. Whether you reimagine it or maintain its spiritual roots, the potential for this historic gem is boundless. Don’t miss out on owning a rare piece of history with limitless opportunities!

Subject property is on south side of New Haven Ave, east of S Anthony Blvd, West of Birchwood Ave